“One Body”
A Review of That
They May Be One by Nick Olszyk
Distribution Service: Fathom Entertainment
FCC Rating, G
OSV Rating, Not rated at the time of this review
Reel Rating, Two Reels
The
Dicastery for Promoting Christian Unity may be a recent development, but its
roots go much deeper, all the way back to Christ’s priestly prayer in John 17,
that “they may be one, just as You, Father, are in Me, and I in You.” That
They May Be One, which takes its name from this passage, is a new documentary
that looks at the history of the ecumenical movement and its role in the
church. While slow and somewhat vague in parts, it does capture the desire of
the Church to bridge the divides between Christian groups in meaningful way.
What is less clear, but more urgent, is how this movement will continue into
the 21st century.
The film
starts with an intriguing coincidence. In the 2nd half of the 19th
century, an Italian nun named Elena Guerra, who was canonized by Pope Francis
just two years ago, felt a strong call to spread devotion to the Holy Spirit.
She started a religious order devoted to the third person of the Trinity and
wrote to Pope Leo XIII in 1885, encouraging the Holy Father to invoke and
dedicate the 20th century to Him. On January 1st, 1901,
Leo XIII did just that, beginning the year with the classic prayer “Veni
Sanctus Spiritus.” On the exact same day, a group of preachers, including
William Seymor and Agnes Ozman, were praying at a church in Topeka, Kansas when
there was a “sudden outpouring of the Holy Spirit,” and they began speaking in
tongues. This is generally considered the start of the Pentecostal movement in
the United States. Thus began John Paul II’s hope that as “the 2nd
millennium was the era of Christian disunity, the 3rd millennium
would be the era of Christian re-unity.”
Using these
events as a springboard, the film traces the history of the ecumenical movement
through this last century to the present, interviewing many Catholic and
Protestant leaders, though the Orthodox seem largely absent. For the first time
in centuries, there is real, serious dialogue between multiple parties that
lead to profound events such as the lifting of mutual excommunications between
the Pope and ecumenical patriarch in 1965 or Joint Statement on Justification
in 1999. More than these declarations, however, is the common love for Jesus
expressed mutual prayer and charity. The ultimate mark of a Christian is love,
and when Christians of all stripes can love together, it will bring not just
unity in structure but deepen holiness.
This does
negate pitfalls or difficulties along the way. The film readily acknowledges
the fear that ecumenical hopes could lead to a watering down of faith or even
denial of doctrine. The key is not changing the true teachings of the faith but
willing to engage the other and building faith in Jesus Christ. This includes
being honest about theological differences and accepting where lines cannot be
crossed. If someone will not believe the Eucharist is Body and Blood of Christ,
they should not receive Him. That would hinder unity through sacrilege rather
than build faith. However, we can pray together and serve together.
The first
act of the documentary that covers the Holy Spirit is quite compelling, but the
film quickly loses momentum and never recovers. The second act drags on
terribly with multiple interviewers repeating the same message. It also leans
heavily on personal experience rather than examining concrete actions by the
Church and misses several key developments like the rise of apologetics, social
media, the Eastern Catholic churches, or the Anglican ordinariates. While the
intentions of the documentary are sound, it is light on solutions. Yes, Christ
does will that all Christians “be one,” yet this will happen under the mantle
of His Church. It would be interesting exploration to envision how this will
occur in the future, but we’ll have to wait for another documentary for that.
This article first appeared in Catholic World Report on May 6th, 2026.

Comments
Post a Comment